Finding 10 Ranger goalies to make the list was difficult, but with the defenseman, the difficulty was trimming the list down to 10. So here they are, the 10 best Ranger Dmen of my time.
- Sergei Zubov, and Dave Maloney.
I thought about not putting Zubov on the list. He only played in 165 games as a Ranger, but he was just too good a player during that time to leave out. Zubov had 156 pts in those 165 games, including his being the leading scorer (89 pts) of the ’94 team. An excellent puck mover with great vision and instincts, Zubov was traded away in an awful trade, because his coach held a ridiculous grudge. [Editor’s note: I would have had Zubov much higher on this list]
Maloney was a heart and soul Ranger. The youngest captain in franchise history. Dave played in 650 games as a Ranger. The fun STAT with Maloney were his penalty minutes. 1,113 in his career as a Ranger. Not much of a fighter, but he seemed to find his way to the box.
- Jeff Buekeboom.
Buekeboom was the type of Dman that we wish the Rangers had right now. Rugged, physical, cleared the crease, and protected his teammates. He rode shot gun for Brian Leetch. Jeff played in 520 games as a Ranger, and amassed 1,157 penalty minutes. 1994 Cup champion.
- Barry Beck.
Beck’s Ranger career was wrecked by shoulder injuries. The most famous was the 1984 game 4 hit by Patrick Flatly of the Islanders. When healthy, Beck was a beast. Physical on D, with a very good offensive game, Beck scored 66 goals and had 239 points in his 415 games as a Ranger.
- Dan Girardi.
I wrestled with this one a bit. Did Girardi belong on the list? And if so, where? I settled at 7. How could the number one right side Dman, during a great era of Ranger hockey, be left off the list? Girardi goes against every top forward in the game, and does a terrific job of holding them down. 770 games with the Rangers as an un-drafted FA. He is an original Black, and Blueshirt. While his game has slipped in the past couple of seasons, he has recovered somewhat this season.
- Marc Staal.
When I first saw Staal play, I thought to myself, Larry Robinson. Those long strides while carrying the puck, and the size, had me thinking stud Dman. He just needed to add some nasty to his game. None of that happened. It wasn’t too long ago that I was hoping the Rangers would trade this disappointment. But the more I watched Staal, the more I appreciated his game. Very good with the stick, and excellent at getting body position, and at his best when the game is nasty. Staal has shown there is more than one way to be a shutdown Dman. A career Ranger, with 657 games under his belt.
- Ryan McDonagh.
The Rangers captain was stolen from the Montreal Canadiens, for Scot Gomez, and no Scot Gomez. Powerful skater, strong defender; he is matched up against the top lines of every team. Still manages to contribute offensively with 198 points in 438 games. McDonagh has underrated toughness, as seen in the 2015 playoffs, as he played with a broken foot.
- James Patrick.
In my view, Patrick is a very underrated Ranger. A tremendous skater, Patrick was as fast backwards as a lot guys were forwards. An offensive defenseman, Patrick had 467 points in his 671 games as a Ranger. He was traded during the ’94 season in a deal that involved Steve Larmer. Keenan was not a fan, and Patrick had become redundant with the emergence of Sergie Zubov.
- Ron Greschner.
Greschner, in my view, is an all time Ranger. 982 games played, and 610 points. “Young Greschner” was a slow skater, but had a knack for slowing everybody on the opposition down so that he looked faster. A great stick handler, Greschner also had a tough side to him. He was a very willing fighter. Injuries were a big part of Greschner’s career. I would guess he missed well over 100 games in career due to injury. An all time great Ranger, and one of my favorites.
- Brad Park.
The second best Dman in the league many years behind Bobby Orr. Park was an all around Dman, with a lot of offense in his game. 465 games played for the Rangers, and 378 points. Traded to the hated Bruins, in a trade, that at the time made a lot of Ranger fans sick. He was also not afraid to drop the gloves, and would often drop them against Philly.
- Brian Leetch.
The greatest drafted Ranger player. I would argue that he is simply the greatest Ranger ever. 1,129 games, and 981 points as a Ranger. The bigger the stakes, the bigger Leetch played. Rookie of the year, two time Norris trophy winner, and the Conn Smyth trophy in 1994. Stanley Cup champion. My personal favorite game of Leetch was in the second round of the ’95 playoffs. Game two against Philly. It was the most dominant game I have ever seen him play. He scored a hat trick, and was all over the place. They lost the game 4-3 in OT, but I remember shaking my head at how good he was. In a 33 playoff game stretch that covered the ’94 and ’95 playoffs, Leetch scored 17 goals and had 48 points! During his Ranger career, his teammates included Guy LaFleur, Marcel Dionne, Mark Messier, and Wayne Gretzky.
Sorry bulldog, but I can’t take any Ranger list seriously that doesn’t include Tom Poti.
Poti was an offensive force and the greatest shutdown D man in ranger history. Opposing players never went anywhere near the crease when Poti was patrolling the D zone.
LikeLiked by 1 person
any post that leaves out Scott Kleinendorst is a post I will boycott
LikeLike
Bdl
Great work
LikeLike
obviously, it’s Leetch, Park and everyone else, but in my opinion McD and Beuk are 3&4 or 4&3
LikeLike
But where is strudwick, or ndur, or purinton, or brad brown, or reitz, or featherstone?
–
And mon dieu, how is Brady skjel not on that list? Just ask 90% of the current posters here, he should be 1B next to leetch.
LikeLike
I agree with the top 3 and I think he’s got all of the right names, but the order of 4-10 is not what I would have done. I’d probably go McDonagh, Zubov, Patrick, Beuk, Staal, Beck, Girardi.
LikeLike
Good morning, boneheads!
Very nice, BDL! I love the fact that you included Girardi on that list. Yes, his game deteriorated, and yes, they have to buy him out. But you can’t deny him of what he means to this organization, and what he had to pay to make this team strong over the years.
LikeLiked by 1 person
As i mentioned, Patrick was a very underrated Ranger, and I think you (RR2) are underrating him now. Patrick should be at 4. 5 through 10 you can shuffle.
LikeLike
I don’t think I am underrating him. I think you’ve underrated McDonagh and Zubov. I think those three are all really close, but the drop from Patrick to Beuk (on my list) is pretty significant.
I also heavily weigh playoff performance and Patrick was an underperformer.
LikeLike
And if they hadn’t stupidly dealt away Zubov, he’d probably be #3 on this list.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I would say he could challenge for #2, but if I am going to play the “if they didn’t trade him away” card for Zubov, then I’d have to play it for Park, and Park would still remain #2.
LikeLike
Stu Bickel was also great on faceoffs.
Great job, BDL. Agree very much that Patrick was underrated and under-appreciated.
LikeLike
I had a friend who was a huge James Patrick fan and I used to bust her chops all the time by saying the Rangers should have drafted Al MacInnis instead.
LikeLike
enjoyed this
LikeLike
Could you guys imagine what a skater/player like Brian Leetch (in particular) would be like in today’s NHL?
He’s got Crosby-level skills, imo.
LikeLike
I know he has scored far prettier goals,
But I still get verklempt and goosebumps when I even THINK of Leetch’s goal đŸ¥… shortside in Game 7, 1994…
My God.
LikeLike
Give Donuts a top-flight partner and again we will see the Crosbys and the Ovechkins shut down.
LikeLike
And to think, all he cost us was clearing Scott Gomez off of our cap.
LikeLike
Looks like Buch out for Puempel. I do not like this move, at all.
LikeLike
Yandle? Where is Yandle? Greatest hockey player ever and he is not on the list?!
RIGGED!
LikeLike
I don’t like it either, but you could see it coming.
LikeLike
What no Roman Ndur or Rich Pilon?
Bergevin has been waiting for two year for the Bs to fire Julien. Other than win the Cup there”s nothing Therrien could have done to save his job once Julien was available. Maybe they will dive less now.
LikeLike
I thought Butch stunk in Columbus and AV prob needs to get Pump a game.
LikeLike
A lot of classic names, but everyone is forgetting the two defensemen who helped bring this franchise back to respectability: Malik and Rozsival.
LikeLike
Carp, are you saying don’t play the kids?
LikeLike
ECF or SCF, Admiral?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Also, don’t let Mr. Dolan see you saying anyone on the Rangers stunk! Lifetime bans!
LikeLike
Had to be talking about ECF. The SCF goal was just having the patience to score into a wide open goal.
Not like this:
LikeLike
Btw, nowadays Ron Greschner is a drunken lunatic who tells everyone who disagrees with him to get out of *his* America!
LikeLike
CCCP, I did not know that.
LikeLike
See, Doodie…if you had a Facebook, you would know đŸ˜‰
LikeLike
You have a link to anything of him behaving that way?
LikeLike
Not anymore. He blocked me after I told him what I think of him lol
LikeLike
Eddie the Mouth can confirm this. #FuggRonGreschner
LikeLike
thx …good read …think Zubov and McD should be higher
LikeLike
“Young legs, Jim!”
LikeLike
Carp hates young players. He hasn’t even been with MSG for 10 mins and he’s already buying into AV’s propaganda đŸ™‚
LikeLiked by 1 person
a few honorable mentions
ruotsalainen
jimmy nielsen
vadnais
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_New_York_Rangers_players
LikeLike
Nice job again, BDL. 71 points in 91-92 for Patrick. Overlooked that season as Leetch had 102 points and pretty under rated in his time here. Another guy who I wish could have gotten his name on the Cup in ’94.
LikeLike
Didn’t Patrick go into coaching?
LikeLike
In his e-mail to me, BDL said he wanted to find a spot for Reijo and for Tom Laidlaw.
LikeLike
Alexander Karpovtsev
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have a spot for Reijo- right beside McD. wasn’t he a rhd? he’s only 56. Chelios was barely in his prime at 56. had 30+ years ahead of him!
LikeLike
Great list and I can’t quibble. I would have found a spot for Rexy. May over Girardi who I’ve always felt was a bit overrated. I agree on Patrick and zubov
LikeLike
i thought of laidlaw too as honorable mention too.
LikeLike
Caber!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
From a talent perspective Zubov belongs higher but agree his lack of games in a NYR sweater drops him lower on list.
.
Girardi should be on the list, no doubt. Agree Reijo and Vadnais are honorable mention.
.
Tinordi? Faulk? Driver? Ozolinsh? Startling omissions…
LikeLike
Tremendously moving piece from Corey Hirsch on the Player’s Tribune.
LikeLike
I was referring to Leetch’s goal in the SCF.
As I said, it wasn’t a highlight goal, but it’s the one that gives me goosebumps to this very day.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We will have another BDL special for tomorrow, ahead of the game against the Islanders. It’s tremendous.
LikeLike
It took until 1:42 until SC finally mentions Caber???
LikeLike
No Anton “Norris” Stralman?
LikeLike
Matt Hunwick?
(Sure looked like a Norris candidate last night.). Lmao
LikeLike
Mike McEwen wasn’t here a long time, but was as good as Dave M, IMO.
LikeLike
Montreal is supposedly considering a swap of Galchenyuk for Duchene (with other parts involved). Oh man, can we send them Stepan? I love me some Galchenyuk.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Doodie
That whole mtl situation is interesting to me. I’m pretty sure it was a player motivated coup against Michel led by price (starting with the state down incident).
–
Re gally…I’d trade step in a heartbeat for him or duchene.
LikeLike
Jeep is Lindy Ruff’s assistant coach in Dallas – followed him from Buffalo.
Why would you pair Rexi with McDonagh? The Captain would be dead after a couple of games covering up for Reijo. Rexi was a “defenseman” in name only. I remember when the Rangers tried moving him to RW.
CCCP is right about Gresch being out there on Facebook – very right wing. Then again, losing Carol Alt will do that to ya! đŸ™‚
LikeLiked by 1 person
Habs would never deal Galchenyuk for Stepan. Duchene may be Ontario born, but he sounds French-Canadian so Bergevin can trade for him.
BTW, no love for Willie Huber?!? I remember making a Fan Club trip to the Rangers play the Pens the night Huber nailed Mario (I think Huber must have stumbled and tried to use Mario to prop himself up :-)). That night, while enjoying a few Iron Citys with the pens Fan Club, we got to see the sport story where the sports guy referred to Huber as a “Rangers goon”.
LikeLike
Gresch’s politics are his business. Your politics are your business. I would prefer not to be harangued by either side.
LikeLike
No redden on the list?!
LikeLike
I’m not as high as galchenyuk as you guys.
LikeLike
I’m not as stoked about him as duchene
LikeLike
Rangers Report 2.0 – the Hirsch article is incredibly moving. Here is the link – I encourage everyone to read it. http://www.theplayerstribune.com/corey-hirsch-dark-dark-dark/
LikeLike
thank you for that link.
LikeLike
Coos
I don’t care about Greschner’s politics. It’s the way he tells his *fans*, ppl who admired him.since childhood to go puck themselves and calls them all kinds of names just because they might not share his point of view. That’s low.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Carp, thanks for tweeting the link to Hirsch’s story. The more light shed on mental illness and the struggles those who suffer from it go through the better.
LikeLike
Wow – that Article is chilling
LikeLike
I know Corey from his brief stint as a Ranger — and a Black Ace on the Cup team. Terrific guy. I now see him as heroic.
LikeLike
Harry Howell?
LikeLike
When Ruotsalainen got here he spoke zero English. So they taught him two things right away:
“Roast beef sandwich” which became his dinner every single night for a long time.
and “Help, Bubba” for whenever he was in trouble on the ice.
I remember the night Herb Brooks put him on a forward line with Pavelich and either Hedberg or McClanahan in little Boston Garden. Drove the big bad Bruins up a wall.
LikeLike
Dave,
Howell was just before my time.mi never saw him play. This is a list of players I saw.
LikeLike
sounds like Mike Comrie will need some help from Bubba also
LikeLike
with Reijo, I’m glad at least one of the guys from those Ranger teams got to win a Cup
LikeLike
BDL – just saw the “of my time” part. Gotcha.
LikeLike
Comrie?
LikeLike
Mike Comrie in some trouble in his personal life, Carp. Think Billy Tibetts
LikeLike
Isn’t Comrie one of those Avery “seconds” guys?
LikeLike
I take your word for it, 3C, but I know nothing about it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ratzo
LikeLike
I think they taught him to say: “I want effing roast beef sandwich…”
LikeLike
BDL, thank you for the time and effort you put into these. Totally digging it.
Honestly, all of youse add so much to me being a Ranger fan, and my enjoyment of said fandom.
LikeLike
Seedub
Thank you for thanking bdl for taking the time.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I would like to take this time to thank wicky for thanking seedubb for his thanking bdl for taking the time.
LikeLiked by 3 people
And I would like to cede the remainder of my time back to the Chair.
LikeLike
And to anyone facing the Chair at Sing-Sing, more power to ya!
LikeLike
Except you two, you two, not so much.
: )
LikeLike
That Corey Hirsch article had my jaw wide open and often saying “Oh my God”. I would imagine being a goalie probably fed his OCD because of the pressure and self-doubt a professional must feel. Heck, I was a Thursday night warrior in pickup games at Rye waaay back in the day and i used to relieve every goal against. I can’t even imagine what must go through the mind of someone who does it for a living.
LikeLike
SeeeDubbb is so cheap, he has a colon and parenthesis instead of a yellow smiley. đŸ™‚
LikeLiked by 1 person
Did you say that you would relieve yourself after every goal against?
LikeLike
Fir those who didn’t see the Mike Comrie stories: http://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/2017/02/15/woman-accuses-hilary-duffs-ex-husband-mike-comrie-rape.html
LikeLike
I don’t go in for the new fangled stuff.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I never saw Harry Howell either, but one quote from him always stuck in my head. After winning the Norris Trophy in 1967 he said, “I might as well enjoy it now, because I expect it’s going to belong to Bobby Orr from now on.” Orr’s string of eight in a row was ended by injury and some guy named Potvin in 1976.
LikeLike
Julien gets 5 years 5 mill per from Le Herbs making him 3rd highest paid coach in the league behind Quenville and Babcock.
Julien should call and thank Babcock for that.
LikeLike
Julien should also give a shout out to GM Don Sweeney in Boston for firing him.
FYI = Gustav Nyquist got six games for his high stick on Jared Spurgeon.
LikeLike
I said Bab-cock.
LikeLike
Reijo Ruotsalainen would be on my Top Ten list not for any rational reason other than, man, I loved watching him play. And STILL getting over the Zubov trade. Just about killed me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ugh, on Comrie.
Six games for Nyqvist. I guess NHL Player Safety’s VCR broke.
LikeLike
Per my comment last week, Spurgeon cross checks Nyquist in the kidneys with malice which is commonplace and turns around to retaliate. If they call the first penalty, the second never happens. Can’t understand why the refs let that cheap arse chicken crappe play go when guys are unprotected on the boards.
LikeLike
pathetic NHL refs always let that one go, BDL. You’re right. The guy who decided double minor for Nyquist should be suspended too.
LikeLike
http://nypost.com/2017/02/15/rangers-star-sells-tribeca-loft-in-same-building-as-taylor-swift/
nice digs
LikeLike
Another day, no game. Rangers take more time off than Messier’s barber.
LikeLike
Thought this was funny. Claude Julien seen going through customs.
https://mobile.twitter.com/pengellyink/status/831671919464345600/photo/1
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder what would the list of 10 worst defensemen look like. Oh, man, 10 wouldn’t cut it. Dave Karpa?
LikeLike
Lol, Booby
LikeLike
The Zubov trade sucked BALLS. (Sorry, there’s no other way to put it)
LikeLiked by 1 person
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Michael Sauer thing really breaks my heart. kid seemed to be on track to being a reliable top 4. Real shame.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Top 10 worst Dmen? Probably start off going something like…
-Poti
-Karpa
-Ndur
-Redden
-Lefebvre
-Quintal
LikeLike
Maybe Mironov or Malakhov…
LikeLike
I don’t think you can put Lefebvre, Malakhov or even Redden in the bottom 10 … there were some awful, awful, awful defensemen over the years. But Karpa and Ulanov would be a good start. …
LikeLiked by 1 person
Peter Fiorentino. Dennis (the Menace) Vial. Purinton. Jay More. Petr Smrek. Jeff Woywitka. Michael Kostka. Thomas Pock. Laviolette. General Richmond.
LikeLike
Dude, leave quintal out of this, he was not that bad.
LikeLike
Driver was bad, so was popovich
LikeLike
Am I the only one who thinks the flames coach looks like max headroom?
LikeLike
Heartbreaking article by Corey Hirsch.
OCD- isn’t treatable. Preventable? There is a debate. Remember these times when your toddlers made a big mess while eating their food at a table? Start with sitting on your hands.
LikeLike
Richie Pilon
LikeLike
Tinordi
LikeLike
Kidding
LikeLike
Thanks BDL Leetch was amazing should never been traded!
LikeLike
Steve Eminger
LikeLike
Quintal was definitely the worst. The way he was crying about wanting to go somewhere else… typical frenchy đŸ˜›
LikeLike
Should Darius Kasparaitis be on the worst dman list? Guy was fearless.
LikeLike
Caber!!
LikeLike
Corey Hirsch – what a harrowing story. All the best to him and to all those other innocents similarly afflicted.
LikeLike
*NEW POST*
LikeLike